Early childhood teachers and advocates warned on 22 November 2026 that New Zealand’s minimum staffing ratios can leave tamariki without adequate supervision.
The warnings, reported by NZ Herald, describe services meeting regulatory requirements on paper while individual teachers juggle nappy changes, breaks and children moving between indoor and outdoor spaces. Teachers’ union NZEI Te Riu Roa, an anonymous teacher and sector advocates say clearer rules and proper funding are needed to make care safe in practice.
What early learning ratios require
The regulations broadly require one teacher for every five children under 2, and one for every 10 older children. Ratios must be maintained whenever children are present, with another staff member stepping in when a teacher takes a break.
Zane McCarthy of NZEI Te Riu Roa said teachers often struggled to work within those limits. He described a centre where two teachers were responsible for 20 children over 2, without cover for nappy changes.
“While one teacher was changing nappies the other would have to be basically straddling the door between inside and outside in order to keep an eye on 19 other children,” he said.
McCarthy said he did not know whether that arrangement was legal, but it was neither safe nor good practice. He argued that unclear legislative direction allowed employers to exploit grey areas, with consequences for children and staff.
The Education Review Office, which reviews early learning centres, confirmed that adults cannot be counted while preparing or serving food, doing administrative or maintenance work, taking lunch or rest breaks, or using non-contact time.
Teachers changing nappies or helping children in the bathroom can still be counted because that care takes place within the licensed area. The office stressed that minimum ratios and adequate supervision are separate considerations: meeting one does not automatically secure the other.
Why minimum staffing does not guarantee safe care
An early childhood teacher, speaking anonymously to RNZ, said parents often had little visibility of what happened after centre doors closed. She said some services counted teachers during lunch breaks, sometimes requiring them to remain on the premises.
“This is the best centre I have worked in, and I have worked in quite a few, and there still isn’t any cover for breaks,” she said.
She called for explicit regulations and enough funding to hire additional teachers. In her view, staff should count towards a ratio only when they can respond immediately to the children in their care.
Early years advocate Susan Bates takes the same position on nappy changes and other duties that draw a teacher away from the group. She said those teachers could not respond quickly and should not be included in the calculation.
Bates said a survey of 400 teachers in a social media group she runs found that only 40 per cent believed their services maintained ratios at all times. Others might employ enough teachers across the whole building while individual rooms fell below the required level.
The survey is not an official measure of the sector, but its accounts point to a practical gap between centre-wide staffing and supervision where children actually are. Bates said some teachers believed one adult could supervise 25 children outdoors provided enough colleagues were elsewhere on the premises.
“Teachers are distraught basically. They’ve been telling me for a long time that they just cannot care for children under these circumstances,” she said.
Bates linked that pressure to rising behavioural needs and reduced supervision, describing the situation as unfair to children and teachers alike.
Rules written for a different early childhood system
Te Rito Maioha Early Childhood New Zealand, which represents several hundred services, agrees that the requirements are complex and widely misunderstood. General manager Nikki Parsons said centres can count total staff and children across the service rather than room by room, but argued that this must change.
“If you’ve got 10 under-two with two staff members, one of them goes to change a nappy, they’re leaving one staff member then with nine children so in theory you’re meeting the regulatory requirements but you’re not meeting quality care for our tamariki at all,” she said.
Parsons said the ratios dated from 1960, when early learning commonly involved three- and four-year-olds attending for three hours a day. Children can now attend for up to 10 hours, with services caring for infants and toddlers alongside five- and six-year-olds.
That history matters for today’s policy debate. Longer days bring more meals, sleeps, nappy changes and staff breaks, while the minimum staffing framework has not kept pace with how whānau use early learning.
What reform would mean for tamariki and whānau
Te Rito Maioha wants one teacher for every four children under 3, and one for every eight children aged 3 to 5. Parsons said lower ratios must come with proper Government funding, because services cannot deliver them under current resourcing.
The distinction is central. Tighter legal wording could stop services counting unavailable staff, but without additional money it could also leave operators struggling to provide cover. Better ratios require both enforceable supervision standards and the workforce to meet them.
For parents, the dispute also shows why a centre’s advertised staffing number may not describe a child’s experience throughout the day. The relevant question is whether enough adults are present, available and able to respond in each space, including during routine care and breaks.
The Education Review Office’s position offers a clear benchmark: ratios apply throughout children’s attendance, and supervision must be assessed alongside them. Teachers and sector groups are now asking ministers to turn that principle into rules that reflect daily practice.
Early learning ratios: common questions
What are New Zealand’s current minimum ratios?
The broad requirements are one teacher to five children under 2, and one teacher to 10 children over that age. Services must maintain the minimum whenever children are present.
Can teachers on lunch breaks be counted?
No. The Education Review Office says adults on lunch or rest breaks, non-contact time, food duties, administration or maintenance cannot be counted for ratio purposes.
What changes are early education services seeking?
Te Rito Maioha Early Childhood New Zealand proposes ratios of one to four for under-3s and one to eight for children aged 3 to 5, backed by sufficient Government funding.
