COP31 climate talks in Antalya ran more than a day past their deadline on 22 November 2026, as a fight over fossil fuels pushed a global agreement towards collapse.
Victoria University of Wellington earth sciences professor Tim Naish warned that many countries were losing faith in the annual United Nations summits. Pacific Island nations were among the most frustrated as negotiations dragged on without clear commitments on fossil fuels or climate adaptation finance, RNZ reported.
Deadlock over fossil fuel wording
Talks stalled after a draft agreement omitted any reference to transitioning away from fossil fuels, The Guardian reported. European Union, Pacific Island and African states were pressing for that language, while Saudi Arabia was among the countries understood to be resisting it.
The dispute struck at the purpose of a summit already described as the Implementation COP. Delegates had arrived in Türkiye expecting to discuss how climate finance and adaptation commitments would be delivered, rather than reopen the basic question of whether the world should move away from coal, oil and gas.
During a late-night session, COP31 presidents Australia and Türkiye presented a new package intended to secure consensus. Turkish president Murat Kurum said he believed concerns about fossil fuel wording and funding for developing countries' adaptation programmes had been addressed.
I truly remain hopeful, I still believe that we can arrive at some excellent decisions here in this hall, here in Antalya.
The gap between us is narrowing, and the political will required to build a bridge exists right here in this room, he told the BBC.
A third draft went to delegates in the early hours of the morning. At that stage, there was no final agreement and no certainty that the proposed language would survive the remaining negotiations.
Why Tim Naish fears a COP flop
Naish attended the summit as chair of the World Climate Research Programme. He said COP31 had become one of the least productive climate summits and would be a failure if governments left without a deal.
It was a given that we would continue this so-called roadmap of transitioning away from fossil fuels that people thought wouldn't be controversial.
What can happen at this COP is, essentially it's a flop, and we don't get any traction on the core goals that were set going into this process.
Even a last-minute agreement would not necessarily rescue the summit's credibility. Naish said negotiations had backslid on major issues, and he did not expect any eventual deal to be transformative.
That warning comes as the world moves closer to the Paris Agreement's 1.5C warming threshold. Naish also pointed to the absence of the United States, one of the world's biggest polluters, and to climate change receiving less public attention while other geopolitical crises dominate.
He described a wider erosion of confidence in a process that depends on countries returning each year with stronger commitments and the means to carry them out.
Bottom line is I think people are losing faith in the process, they are not seeing the process working, but I think the majority would be very loathe to leave it, because it's all we've got at the moment.
Pacific nations face the sharpest consequences
For Pacific Island countries, Naish said, the argument over 1.5C is not an abstract diplomatic contest. Their representatives have carried a strong voice at COP negotiations because that level of warming poses what he called an existential threat.
This is why they are at the COP, 1.5 degrees is existential for them.
Karan Titus, a renewable energy engineering researcher at the University of Canterbury who also attended COP31, identified another weakness: the absence of clear pathways for climate adaptation finance. Without them, developing countries face fresh promises without a practical route to fund protection and preparation.
Titus said carbon capture and storage appeared to be offering negotiators a way around the fossil fuel impasse. He warned that relying on the technology could instead lock fossil fuel projects in place for many years.
He described transitioning away from fossil fuels as the foundation of genuine climate action and said the summit would fail in its mission if its central implementation items remained unresolved.
This is bad, as it follows last year's ICJ ruling that parties must adhere to 1.5, and this year's UNEP report that we are on track to overshoot 1.5.
Can the UN climate process still deliver?
An overrun does not automatically mean collapse. Recent climate summits have regularly continued beyond their deadlines before producing agreements, CNBC reported. Isatou Camara, Gambia's finance negotiator, said some countries appeared to be using delay to pressure others into accepting a weaker outcome.
That possibility matters for New Zealand and its Pacific neighbours. Australia holds the COP31 presidency alongside Türkiye, while New Zealand researchers are directly involved in assessing whether the outcome matches the scientific and financial tasks before governments.
Naish's assessment leaves a narrow choice. Countries can preserve the UN process by agreeing on credible action, or continue watering down its decisions while insisting that the process itself must survive.
COP31 climate talks: key questions
What caused the COP31 deadlock?
A draft agreement contained no reference to transitioning away from fossil fuels. The European Union, Pacific Island and African states wanted the wording included, while Saudi Arabia was among those understood to oppose it.
Why is 1.5C so important to Pacific Island nations?
Tim Naish said Pacific representatives regard 1.5C of warming as an existential threat. That explains their frustration when negotiators revisit basic climate commitments instead of agreeing on finance and implementation.
Has COP31 reached a final agreement?
No final deal had been reached when these warnings were reported on 22 November 2026. Australia and Türkiye had proposed a new package, and a third draft was sent to delegates in the early hours of the morning.
