Logan Loughlin gave evidence at the High Court trial of William Collins and Esther Corlett, who both deny murdering Tiwana, the then president of the Mongrel Mob Barbarians. According to the NZ Herald's coverage of the trial, the witness described a night of what he called carnage that began with a confrontation between two gangs outside his house on St John St.
What the witness told the court
Loughlin said the trouble started when members of Black Power Mangu Kaha and the Mongrel Mob Barbarians gathered outside his home. He initially believed senior figures might hold talks, but that hope collapsed when a car came out of nowhere and smashed into Collins' parked ute.
Everyone scattered to their vehicles, he said. Collins' ute had already lost a rear tyre after being rammed, and it wobbling as it crossed St John St. Loughlin said another vehicle then struck the ute, its headlights at his eye level, pushing it onto a grass verge. They were trying to turn around when it was rammed again.
He told the court Collins had instructed the passengers to wind down their windows so they would not get glass in their eyes. When the vehicle stopped, Collins told them to stay in the car.
Loughlin said the wheels were spinning in the grass as the driver tried to reverse, and it was then that he got out and saw Tiwana lying on the grass beneath the vehicle. He said he panicked and wanted to get away.
As he fled toward another vehicle, Loughlin said, he saw Esther Corlett and another passenger get out and stomp on Tiwana's head.
I think we ran someone over.
Loughlin said those words were spoken by Collins, who was driving. Crown prosecutor Richard Jenson asked him whether anything else had been said, and after his memory was refreshed by a police statement, Loughlin repeated the account.
The defence tested that version of events. Steven Lack, one of Collins' lawyers, asked whether it could have been another passenger, Ngamoki Tihi, who said the words. Loughlin replied: Could be, yep. Under re-examination, however, he told Jenson it was Collins who said someone had been hit, and no one else.
Disputes over what the witness actually saw
Rebekah Webby, one of Corlett' lawyers, pressed Loughlin on how much he could have witnessed. She asked him to confirm that what he saw were kicks to Tiwana.
Stomps, Loughlin replied.
Webby suggested he could not have seen much as he ran away, fearing for his life, and he agreed he had not been looking. Jenson then had him review his police statement and asked again what he had seen.
Them kicking him, Loughlin said, adding that he saw this while getting out of the truck.
Why the witness's background matters
The court heard Loughlin had earlier been associated with the Mongrel Mob but was linked to Black Power at the time of the incident. He had been packing up his house to move towns and left Ōpōtiki the following day.
Other evidence before the court
The trial also heard from Tori Tai, who has admitted filling Collins' Holden Colorado with tyres and setting it alight in the days after Tiwana's death.
The trial continues before Justice Andrew Becroft.
FAQ
Who is on trial for Tiwana's death?
William Collins, a Black Power Mangu Kaha member, and his partner Esther Corlett. Both deny murdering Tiwana, who died in Ōpōtiki on 9 June 2023.
What did the witness say happened?
Logan Loughlin told the court he saw Tiwana lying under a ute, gasping for air, and that Corlett and another passenger stomped on his head as he fled.
Where is the trial being held?
The murder trial is being heard before Justice Andrew Becroft at the High Court, and it continues.
